The Chicago Journal

Your Gateway to the Heartbeat of Chicago

Dr. Ian Hardy’s Guide to Assessing Embryo Quality: Choosing the Right Path to Parenthood

Image commercially licensed from:
Image commercially licensed from:

Embarking on the journey to parenthood through assisted reproductive technologies (ART) often involves critical decisions about embryo selection. The quality of the embryo plays a pivotal role in the success of in vitro fertilization (IVF) and other ART procedures. Dr. Ian Hardy, an esteemed expert in Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility, provides invaluable insights into assessing embryo quality and making informed choices on the path to parenthood.

Understanding Embryo Quality

Embryo quality refers to the health and viability of embryos created through ART, particularly IVF. It is a key determinant of the likelihood of a successful pregnancy. Assessing embryo quality involves evaluating various characteristics to identify the embryos with the highest potential for implantation and healthy development.

Dr. Hardy emphasizes the significance of embryo quality assessment in the ART process. “The quality of the embryo is a critical factor in achieving a successful pregnancy through ART,” he states. “Understanding how to assess and select high-quality embryos is essential for couples seeking to build their families through assisted reproduction.”

Embryo Grading

Embryo grading is a standardized method used to assess embryo quality in IVF. It involves evaluating specific criteria to assign a grade to each embryo. While grading systems may vary between fertility clinics, some common factors are typically considered:

Cell Number: Embryos with the optimal number of cells at specific developmental stages are often considered of higher quality.

Cell Uniformity: Uniformity in the size and shape of the cells in an embryo is an indicator of better quality.

Fragmentation: Minimal fragmentation, where small fragments of cells are present, is preferred.

Symmetry: A well-defined, symmetrical embryo is often considered higher quality.

Blastocyst Development: For embryos allowed to develop to the blastocyst stage, the degree of expansion and the formation of distinct cell types are assessed.

Dr. Hardy notes that grading is a valuable tool but emphasizes its limitations. “Embryo grading is a useful guideline, but it is not foolproof,” he cautions. “It provides valuable information, but other factors must also be considered in the decision-making process.”

Advanced Techniques in Embryo Assessment

In addition to traditional grading methods, advanced techniques have emerged to enhance embryo assessment. These include:

Time-lapse Imaging: Time-lapse imaging allows continuous monitoring of embryo development, providing detailed insights into key developmental milestones and potential abnormalities.

Preimplantation Genetic Testing (PGT): PGT allows for the screening of embryos for genetic abnormalities, reducing the risk of implanting embryos with severe genetic conditions.

Metabolomic Analysis: Metabolomic profiling examines the chemical compounds produced by embryos during development, offering a comprehensive view of their health.

Dr. Hardy underscores the benefits of incorporating these advanced techniques when assessing embryo quality. “Time-lapse imaging and PGT can provide additional information about embryo viability,” he says. “However, they should be used judiciously, based on individual patient circumstances and needs.”

Factors Affecting Embryo Quality

Embryo quality can be influenced by various factors, both intrinsic and extrinsic. Dr. Hardy highlights some of the key factors that can impact embryo quality:

Age: The age of the woman providing the eggs is a crucial determinant of embryo quality. Younger women tend to produce higher-quality eggs and embryos.

Ovarian Reserve: A woman’s ovarian reserve, which reflects the quantity and quality of her eggs, can affect embryo quality.

Stimulation Protocol: The medications and protocols used during ovarian stimulation in IVF can impact egg and embryo quality.

Lifestyle Factors: Lifestyle factors such as smoking, alcohol consumption, and obesity can negatively influence embryo quality.

Sperm Quality: The quality of sperm used for fertilization also plays a role in embryo quality.

Dr. Hardy emphasizes that while these factors can influence embryo quality, advances in ART have made it possible to overcome many challenges. “Even in cases where there are factors affecting embryo quality, innovative approaches and individualized treatment plans can improve the chances of a successful pregnancy,” he explains.

Tailored Approaches to Embryo Selection

The selection of embryos should be a personalized process, taking into account the unique circumstances and needs of each patient. Dr. Ian Hardy underscores the importance of a tailored approach.

“Every patient is different, and their journey to parenthood may involve distinct challenges,” he notes. “It is crucial for healthcare providers to work closely with patients, understanding their medical history, preferences, and goals, in order to make informed decisions regarding embryo selection.”

The Role of Preimplantation Genetic Testing (PGT)

Preimplantation Genetic Testing (PGT) is a powerful tool in embryo assessment, allowing for the detection of genetic abnormalities before embryo implantation. Dr. Hardy emphasizes the significance of PGT in certain cases.

“PGT can be invaluable for couples with a history of genetic disorders or advanced maternal age,” he explains. “It can help reduce the risk of transferring embryos with serious genetic conditions and improve the chances of a healthy pregnancy.”

However, Dr. Hardy also cautions against overuse of PGT. “PGT is not necessary for all patients,” he says. “It should be considered on a case-by-case basis, guided by a thorough evaluation of the patient’s medical history and genetic risk factors.”

Optimizing Success Through Single Embryo Transfer

While the desire for a successful pregnancy often leads to the temptation to transfer multiple embryos, Dr. Ian Hardy advocates for single embryo transfer (SET) in most cases. SET involves transferring a single high-quality embryo, minimizing the risk of multiple pregnancies and associated complications.

“The goal of ART should be to achieve a healthy singleton pregnancy,” he emphasizes. “Transferring a single high-quality embryo not only reduces the risk of complications but also increases the likelihood of a successful pregnancy with a healthy outcome.”


Assessing embryo quality is a critical aspect of the assisted reproductive journey. Dr. Ian Hardy, with his extensive expertise in Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility, provides invaluable guidance on navigating this complex process. While embryo grading and advanced techniques offer valuable insights, the key to success lies in individualized care, patient collaboration, and judicious use of tools like PGT. Through a personalized approach to embryo selection, couples can enhance their chances of achieving the dream of parenthood.

About Dr. Ian Hardy

Dr. Ian Hardy’s academic and professional background includes being a Fulbright Scholar, receiving grant support for his research, and being board certified in Obstetrics and Gynecology, as well as Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility. He has an AB degree in Biology and minors in Science in Human Affairs and Theatre from Princeton University, and he earned his MD and PhD degrees from the University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, followed by his residency at Stanford University School of Medicine and fellowship at Harvard Medical School.

Share this article


This article features branded content from a third party. Opinions in this article do not reflect the opinions and beliefs of The Chicago Journal.