The Chicago Journal

Beyoncé’s ‘Church Girl’ Beat: A Twist of Destiny

Image commercially licensed from: DepositPhotos

In a fascinating twist of fate, Beyoncé’s track, “Church Girl,” from her Renaissance album, was not originally meant for her. Renowned producer No I.D. had created the instrumental beat while working with JAY-Z, but the beat took an unexpected journey, finding its home on Beyoncé’s album. Let’s delve into the intriguing story behind this musical twist, exploring the creative process, the dynamics between artists, and the broader implications of musical innovation.

The Genesis of the Beat:

No I.D., the mastermind behind the beat, shared insights into its creation. He was at the couple’s home, working with JAY-Z, when he crafted the instrumental melody. “I was at [their] house one day, and I had some equipment with me, and I just started making a beat,” explained the 52-year-old producer. “And he was rapping to it, it was for him. And he just put it in the computer, I never thought about it again, I literally forgot about it.” This moment captures the spontaneity and creative energy that often defines the birth of exceptional music.

Beyoncé’s Sneak Move:

No I.D.’s revelation took an interesting turn when he received multiple calls from JAY-Z, who proposed the idea of Beyoncé using the beat for her album. “Jay jokingly tells me, ‘Man, she stole my beat. She was like, ‘Remember that idea in the computer that you didn’t finish?'” No I.D. recounted. This anecdote sheds light on the interconnectedness of artists and the collaborative nature of music production.

Collaborative Conversations:

As the story unfolds, No I.D. met with Beyoncé to discuss the possibility of her using the beat for her album. They engaged in creative discussions, listened to her album, and the beat found its place as the seventh track on “Renaissance.” The collaboration between No I.D. and Beyoncé showcases the importance of open communication and artistic exchange in the music industry.

A Musical Departure:

No I.D. is known for his roots in house music, yet “Church Girl” represents a departure from this genre. He initially aimed to contribute a house-inspired track but remembers Beyoncé saying, “Nah, we got this ‘Church Girl’ record.” The evolution of musical styles is a testament to Beyoncé’s versatility as an artist. It also highlights the significance of artists pushing boundaries and exploring new horizons.

Reception and Artistic Diversity:

Notably, “Church Girl” has received mixed responses, with some loving it and others not quite convinced. No I.D. sums it up beautifully, saying, “It’s art. Usually, when music is divisive, that means it’s something new. To each their own, some people like raspberry ice cream too.” This artistic diversity underscores the subjective nature of music and its capacity to elicit various emotions and interpretations.

Beyond the Music:

Beyoncé’s Renaissance World Tour recently concluded, taking her to 39 cities across the globe. For fans who missed the live experience, a cinematic treat awaits with “Renaissance: A Film by Beyoncé,” scheduled for screenings at AMC Theatres starting Dec. 1. This concert film captures the magic of her September performances in her hometown of Houston. The extension of a live concert experience into a visual medium adds a new layer of creativity and engagement for fans.


The story of “Church Girl” serves as a testament to the unpredictability of the music industry. It highlights how creative sparks can lead to unexpected yet delightful outcomes. Beyoncé’s ability to recognize the potential of the beat and make it her own underscores her artistry. As the music world evolves, such tales of musical evolution continue to captivate audiences, emphasizing the ever-evolving and dynamic nature of the industry. This story not only showcases the musical journey but also the relationship between artists and the evolution of artistic expression.